If you are looking at renting a Florida house by the room, two different things come up in the search: PadSplit, and full-service co-living property management. They are not competing versions of the same product. Understanding what each one actually is saves you from buying the wrong thing.
Everything below about PadSplit comes from their own published material, with the source and the date we checked it. Everything about Avenir is what we actually do. Where we are giving an opinion, we say so.
What PadSplit publishes about itself
Source: padsplit.com/hosts, retrieved 21 September 2026. Platform terms change, so confirm anything decision-critical with PadSplit directly before you commit a property.
PadSplit describes itself as "a housing marketplace that connects property owners with pre-screened residents seeking an affordable place to live," and says it helps owners "leverage under-utilized space in their existing properties to make it more profitable."
On that page, PadSplit states that it provides:
- Pre-screening and identity verification of members
- Member approval against stated income and employment criteria
- Membership enforcement through rules, fines and strikes
- Property selection and preparation guidance, including detailed furnishing requirements
It also publishes performance figures for its own network: hosts earning "2.5X more rental income," average occupancy "above 90%," average member tenure of "eight months across all of our homes," and an Atlanta host average of "$4,649 a month." Those are PadSplit's numbers for PadSplit's network, not independently verified, and Atlanta is not Florida.
That page does not publish fee or commission terms. We are not going to guess at them. Ask PadSplit what they charge and what stays with you.
What Avenir actually does
We are a licensed Florida brokerage operating co-living properties room by room. On a full-service engagement we handle marketing and room listing, applicant screening against consistent criteria, lease preparation, rent collection and accounting, maintenance coordination and vendor management, inspections, move-ins and move-outs, room turnovers, access control, rule enforcement, resident issues, and owner reporting.
Our standard co-living management fee is 12 percent. We also offer placement only, where we fill the room for a per-placement fee and you run day-to-day operations yourself.
We manage co-living properties in Central Florida, Tampa Bay, Jacksonville and North Central Florida, and we provide full-service co-living property management for owners in Miami, Fort Lauderdale and South Florida.
The distinction that actually matters
A marketplace and a property manager solve different problems. A marketplace is about reaching people looking for a room. A manager is about what happens at the house: the turnover between residents, the repair call on a Saturday, the resident who is not following the house rules, the room that has been empty three weeks and needs someone to work out why.
These are not necessarily exclusive. Depending on how you want to operate, a property can use a marketplace for resident acquisition while a third-party manager runs operations. If that is the structure you want, confirm what each side permits before you set it up.
What we have seen operating room-by-room in Florida
This section is our own operating experience, not a claim about any platform.
The workload of room-by-room is not four times a single-family lease, but it is not close to one either. Four rooms means four move-ins, four move-outs, four sets of questions, and four opportunities per year for a vacancy. Owners who budget their time as though it were an annual lease are the ones who come looking for a manager around month six.
Turnover is the number that decides the year. A room that sits empty for three weeks between residents costs more than most owners model, and the fix is operational rather than financial: photos ready before the outgoing resident leaves, the clean scheduled, the listing live the same week.
Utilities, internet and common-area cleaning are usually the operator's cost in this model. Any comparison that quotes gross rent without netting those out is not telling you what you will keep.
How much more does renting by the room earn?
The arithmetic is simple. A 4-bedroom house that would rent for $1,600 a month whole-unit, with four rooms at $800, grosses $3,200.
Treat that as arithmetic, not as a market forecast. Real figures depend on the specific house, the submarket, the room sizes and the condition. And gross rent is not return. Net out the higher turnover, the operator-paid utilities, and management before you compare anything to a traditional lease.
What we think, plainly
This is opinion, offered as such.
The question is not which company is better. It is what job you are hiring for. If you want reach and tooling and you intend to operate the property yourself, a marketplace may be the right purchase. If you want the house run without it becoming your second job, that is property management, and it is a different purchase. Some owners want both.
What we would not do is pick either one on the strength of a headline income multiple. Ask for the operating detail, then decide.
Working with Avenir
If you already run a property on a room-rental platform and want someone local operating it, or you are deciding how to set one up, we will walk through the numbers on your specific property.
Contact Avenir Real Estate Brokers for a property-specific income analysis.
Key Takeaways- A co-living marketplace and a full-service property manager solve different problems and are not interchangeable.
- PadSplit's published host material is the only reliable source for what it currently covers. Confirm fees and responsibilities with them directly.
- Renting by the room raises gross income because it raises the operating load. The real decision is who carries that load.
- Gross rent is not return. Net out turnover, operator-paid utilities and management.
- Avenir's co-living management fee is 12 percent, with a placement-only option.
Frequently Asked Questions
Ready to Maximize Your Co-Living Returns?
Get a free income analysis and see what your property could earn with professional co-living management.
Get Free Analysis